Aunty Spam's
Slam a Spammer Blog

Home RSS Archives Aunty's CAN-SPAM eBook with FREE pdf! Spam & the Law Conference Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe with Bloglines
SEND A QUESTION OR COMPLIMENT TO AUNTY! BE SURE TO ADD THE .com AT THE END!

August 27, 2004

Is Your Email Address Safe in the Hands of a Government Agency? Publisher Demands Mailing List from City Council

Posted 2 weeks, 2 days ago on August 27, 2004
Now here's an interesting showdown with potentially far-reaching ramifications.

The location:

o Mar Vista, a suburb of Los Angeles, California

The players:

o The Mar Vista Neighborhood Council, a public body of volunteer neighborhood do-gooders, certified by the city as an advisory agency for the city.

o The Westmar Sun, "a Web journal of news and opinion about Mar Vista and the Westdales", which also sends its content out as an email newsletter.

The story, as reported by the American Reporter:

The Mar Vista Neighborhood Council volunteers are tasked with keeping their constituents updated as to their workings in the community. Many of the council members communicate with their constituents by email.

The Westmar Sun demanded that the Council turn over all of their constituents' email addresses to the Westmar Sun. Westmar claimed that as the Council was a public agency, they were obligated under California law to allow any citizen to view their public records, including the list of citizen email addresses.

The Council, for understandable reasons, were not inclined to want to do this. In fact, rather than breach the privacy of their constituents by sharing their email addresses, and on the advice of their attorney, they destroyed the email addresses. And from now on, they will advise people that if they provide an email address, it may become a matter of public record.

Now there's an interesting way for spammers to build their email base. Kind of makes you wonder about the safety of a Do Not Email list maintained by the government, doesn't it?

Kissy kissy,

Aunty


The trackback url for this post is http://www.aunty-spam.com/bblog/trackback.php/86/

Re: Is Your Email Address Safe in the Hands of a Government Agency? Publisher Demands Mailing List from City Council

Posted 1 week, 3 days ago by Justin • • • Reply

There' s obviously a gap in the law: there should be a requirement for 'statement of intent' for anybody demending data of this nature.

Trackback URL : http://www.aunty-spam.com/bblog/trackback.php/86/311/

Re: Is Your Email Address Safe in the Hands of a Government Agency? Publisher Demands Mailing List from City Council

Posted 1 week, 3 days ago by Tyler M. • • • Reply

While the statement of intent rule would be nice, it would have free speech advocates in an uproar. 'Why should you have to explain to a government agency why you want public information?' - such a rule would allow for easier censorship, which technically this could be considered a case of. Still, it's too bad the Westmar Sun had to abuse the law to bring to light this problem.

Trackback URL : http://www.aunty-spam.com/bblog/trackback.php/86/313/

Add Comment

( to reply to a comment, click the reply link next to the comment )

 
Comment Title
 
Your Name:
 
Email Address:
Make Public?
 
Website:
Make Public?
 
Comment:
 
 
 

Recently

Guy Kawasaki on the Art of...
Dmail: Alternative to...
News Flash: SpamCop and...
For Sale: Your Email...
Who are the Earliest...

Aunty Spam Provided By ISIPP

CAN-SPAM Teleseminar 5/6/04
CAN-SPAM Teleseminar 5/13/04
Spam & the Law Conference 7/29/04
CAN-SPAM Compliance Pack

Other Blogs & Sites

Fun Anti-Spam Novelty Products
The Spam Blog
Spam Primer
Ask Leo
DadsRights.org




Slam a Spammer
Store!
Powered by bBlog